Test: Which chemicals are used in lube?
Lubes: Many are good choices
In the lube test, the Danish Consumer Council THINK Chemicals has examined ingredients in 29 vaginal lubes, intimate gel and the like.
21 lubes in the test get the best chemical rating. I.e. they are free of perfumes, allergenic ingredients and substances suspected of being endocrine disruptors.
Suspected endocrine disruptors: Test show unwanted chemicals in 4 lubes
An unwanted silicone substance (cyclopentasiloxane) is the main ingredient in 2 of the lubricants in the test.
Cyclopentasiloxane is suspected of being endocrine disruptor and is harmful to the environment. The EU is working to highly restrict the substance for environmental reasons.
Parabens are also suspected of being endocrine disruptors. The test found parabens (methylparaben and sodium methylparaben) in 2 other lubes in the test.
The cocktail effect: Overall exposure to unwanted chemicals can be problematic
A lube with unwanted chemicals probably does not pose a risk per se, although absorption through the mucous membrane may be different from through the skin.
But lubes can contribute to your overall exposure to unwanted chemicals - the so-called cocktail effect. The total amount of unwanted chemicals can be problematic, if you are exposed to it from many different products. For example, it can be problematic in relation to endocrine disruptors.
The concentration of the unwanted silicone substance (cyclopentasiloxane) can be high in the 2 lubes with that substance. The silicone substance is the first ingredient on the declaration and is thus the main ingredient.
Perfume: An allergy will follow you for the rest of your life
A lube with perfume is in contact with sensitive parts of your body.
Therefore, think about whether perfume or allergenic plant extracts are needed in your lube. In the test, 4 lubes contain these ingredients, which can cause allergies.
Perfume is generally a good idea to limit, if you want to reduce your risk of developing perfume allergy.
Condoms and sex toys: Some lubes can damage products
Lubes are available water-based, oil-based and silicone-based. Water-based lube can generally be used for condoms and sex toys.
However, some oil and silicone substances can damage condoms and sex toys.
Check out the instructions on the different products to avoid using a lube that can harm other products.
About the test
The test team at The Danish Consumer Council THINK Chemicals has purchased a large number of lubes in Danish stores and webshops.
After that, we have carried out a so-called declaration test of the products. In other words, we have examined the ingredients lists on the products. The declared content is compared with a large number of lists containing unwanted substances which may have lasting adverse effects.
These effects may for example be allergies or endocrine disruption.
The test is carried out in the same way as the Danish Consumer Council THINK Chemicals assess cosmetics and personal care products in the app ‘Kemiluppen’.
The test does not take into account the concentrations in which the substances are present. It also does not take into account substances that may cause irritation, pH or similar.
This is what we found
The products receive these ratings in the test:
• 21 products are without a number of problematic chemicals and receive best chemical rating (A)
• 4 products contain perfume/plant extracts and receive medium chemical rating (B)
• 4 products contain substances suspected, among other things, of endocrine disruptors and receive the lowest chemical rating (C)
Suspected endocrine disruptors in lube
The drug cyclopentasiloxane is suspected of being an endocrine disruptor.
It is also environmentally problematic and the substance can accumulate in nature. Due to the environmental impact, the EU is working to reduce the permitted use in a number of products to 0.1 percent including lube.
Parabens in the form of methylparaben and sodium methylparaben are included in 2 products. The drugs are suspected of being endocrine disruptors.
It must be assumed that there is no risk in using the specific products in themselves. However, the concentration of cyclopentasiloxane may be high in the products, and it is possible that there is a greater uptake of the substance through the mucous membranes than through the skin.
Which legislation applies?
Lubes can fall under different laws depending on how they are marketed.
If they are designated as medical devices, they will be marked with the CE marking. Lubes may also be designated as cosmetics or be referred to as chemical products.
But lubes are in a legal grey zone and it is not clear, which legislation the products belong to.
The test does not show a significant difference in ingredients in relation to whether they are CE-marked or not.
For further information regarding the test contact project manager Christel Søgaard Kirkeby on firstname.lastname@example.org